What’s is unique about SIA’s five elements of its successful HR practices.
- Describe what is unique about SIA’s five elements of its successful HR practices.
- Evaluate the effectiveness of each element’s contribution toward SIA’s leadership in service excellence and cost effectiveness.
- Despite evidence that such practices help service firms achieve higher company performance, many organizations have not managed to execute them as effectively. Why do you think that is the case?
- Some of SIA’s HR practices would be illegal in the U.S. Is this fair competition, or are those HR practices encouraging a “race to the bottom” in terms of employee rights?
Sample Answer
What is Unique About SIA’s Five Elements of its Successful HR Practices?
Singapore Airlines (SIA) stands out in the airline industry for its consistent delivery of premium service, a characteristic deeply rooted in its distinctive human resource (HR) practices. While many companies apply similar HR concepts, SIA’s uniqueness lies in the extreme rigor, deep integration, and strategic alignment of its five core HR elements, which collectively form a mutually reinforcing system:
- Rigorous Selection and Recruitment: SIA’s hiring process is exceptionally stringent and goes far beyond assessing technical skills. It focuses on identifying innate traits like empathy, warmth, a genuine service orientation, and cultural sensitivity. For cabin crew, this can involve multiple rounds of interviews, psychometric tests, and even informal “tea party” sessions where senior managers observe candidates’ natural social behavior and emotional intelligence. The airline’s selection rate for cabin crew is remarkably low, often reported to be around 3-5% of applicants, allowing them to cherry-pick individuals who are naturally predisposed to service excellence. This initial filter ensures a strong foundation of personality and attitude that is difficult to train.
- Extensive Training and Retraining: SIA invests heavily in training, significantly more than industry averages. New cabin crew undergo a comprehensive 4-month (15-week) training program, which is nearly double the industry norm. This training covers not just safety and technical skills but also hospitality, cultural sensitivity, communication skills, grooming (including skincare and poise), and even gourmet food and wine appreciation. This extensive initial investment is complemented by continuous retraining throughout an employee’s career, ensuring skills remain updated and adapting to new services or technologies. For example, SIA aims for its staff to participate in 100 hours of training per year, fostering continuous learning.