The Financial Risk Of “Doing the Right Thing”

 


Organizations’ leaders are increasingly beginning to realize that corporate social responsibility (CSR) efforts should be tightly linked to their main business activities. Some of the most commonly debated issues surrounding this topic include tax avoidance, deregulation, and compromised product safety in lieu of profits. What do you think? How important is it for organizations to build sustainable businesses that benefit future generations and protect the planet? Are there any companies that you either fully support or refuse to support based on their approach to CSR? In this Discussion, you will explore an example of an organization that incorporates CSR practices and will consider any potential negative financial impacts as well as how to overcome negative outcomes.

 

To prepare for this Discussion:

• Consider examples of CSR practices that could have a negative financial impact (losing business associations, having an unintended negative consequence on another group through CSR practices, etc.). The examples could be from an organization that instituted the business practices or from another group that was directly or indirectly affected by those practices.

• Reminder: Be sure to be aware of any personal biases you may have about the organization or CSR practices you discuss this week. Also, be sure to support your assertions using an evidence-based approach.

 

Post an explanation of how ethical and/or positive social change practices can help an organization mitigate risks of engaging in CSR efforts. In your explanation, do the following:

• Identify at least two examples of CSR practices that had or could have a negative financial impact either for the organization or for other groups. Be sure to include what that potential impact could be.

• Analyze the risks and benefits of instituting CSR practices and include which one outweighs the other (i.e., risks vs. benefits).

• Propose how an adherence to ethical standards and/or a drive toward positive social change can help managers overcome negative outcomes. Include how this adherence could apply to each example you provided.
 

Sample Answer

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Explanation of Risk Mitigation through Ethical and Social Change Practices

Ethical standards and a genuine drive toward positive social change serve as a powerful mitigation strategy for the inherent risks of Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR). When CSR is viewed not as a separate philanthropic department, but as an integral framework for ethical decision-making, it builds social license to operate (SLO) and reputational capital.

. Sustainable Sourcing and Increased Input Costs

CSR Practice: A large apparel retailer commits to sourcing 100% organic cotton and uses sustainable, closed-loop dyeing processes that require expensive, certified machinery and specialized training. This commitment requires the company to drop non-compliant, low-cost suppliers in developing countries.

Potential Negative Financial Impact:

For the Organization: The cost of goods sold (COGS) increases significantly due to higher material costs and capital investment in new equipment. This could lead to a reduction in profit margins in the short-term, especially if the competitive market prevents passing the full cost increase on to consumers. Furthermore, the limited supply of certified organic materials could cause supply chain bottlenecks, leading to lost sales opportunities.

2. Divestment from Profitable, High-Risk Industries

CSR Practice: A major global financial institution announces it will no longer finance or underwrite projects related to new thermal coal mines or certain oil and gas exploration in sensitive ecological regions.