Six Ways of Moral Reasoning and Their Application

Six Ways of Moral Reasoning and Their Application Definitions of Six Ways of Moral Reasoning 1. Deontological Ethics: This ethical framework, associated with philosopher Immanuel Kant, emphasizes duty and adherence to rules. It posits that actions are morally right if they follow a set of rules or duties, regardless of the consequences. 2. Teleological/Utilitarian Ethics: This approach focuses on the outcomes of actions. Utilitarianism, associated with philosophers like Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill, argues that the best action is the one that maximizes overall happiness or utility. 3. Relativism: This moral perspective suggests that moral principles are not absolute but rather culturally bound. What is considered moral in one culture may be deemed immoral in another, emphasizing the importance of social context in ethical reasoning. 4. Egoism: This ethical theory posits that actions are moral if they promote the individual's self-interest. It suggests that individuals should act in ways that benefit themselves, as long as it does not harm others excessively. 5. Emotivism: This perspective views moral judgments as expressions of emotional responses rather than factual statements. According to emotivism, when we say something is good or bad, we are merely expressing our feelings about it. 6. Virtue Theory: Rooted in Aristotelian ethics, this framework emphasizes the importance of character and virtues in determining moral behavior. It focuses on the development of good character traits (virtues) and how they guide ethical decision-making. Role-Playing Scenario Questions and Answers Question 1: Should you help a stranger in need if it puts you at risk? Using Deontological Ethics, I would argue that I have a moral duty to help those in need, regardless of the personal risk involved. According to the principle of duty, it is my obligation to assist others when I can. As stated in Galatians 6:2, "Bear one another's burdens, and so fulfill the law of Christ." Thus, helping the stranger aligns with my moral duties and responsibilities towards others. Question 2: Is it acceptable to lie to protect someone's feelings? From a Teleological/Utilitarian perspective, lying may be justified if it results in greater overall happiness. If telling a lie would spare someone pain without causing significant harm elsewhere, the action could be considered morally acceptable. For example, if a friend is struggling with their self-image, a small white lie about their appearance might temporarily boost their confidence and happiness. Question 3: Is it wrong to impose your moral beliefs on others? Through the lens of Relativism, imposing my moral beliefs on others may be problematic because morality is culturally dependent. Different societies have varying beliefs about what is right or wrong. For instance, while I may believe in certain ethical standards, others might have contrasting views based on their cultural backgrounds. Hence, understanding and respecting these differences is crucial in a diverse world. Question 4: Should you prioritize your needs over those of your family? Applying Egoism, I would say that prioritizing my own needs is reasonable as long as it does not severely compromise my family's well-being. Taking care of myself can enhance my ability to support and care for my family effectively. Therefore, self-interest should guide my decisions, provided they do not lead to significant harm to those I care about. Question 5: How should you respond to someone who acts immorally? Using Emotivism, my response to immorality would stem from my emotional reaction to the situation. If I feel anger or disappointment towards someone’s immoral action, that feeling drives my judgment regarding their behavior. While emotions can provide insight into moral situations, it’s essential to reflect on those feelings critically to ensure a balanced view rather than simply reacting impulsively. Question 6: What is the best way to approach personal character development? From a Virtue Theory standpoint, developing personal character requires cultivating virtues such as honesty, kindness, and courage. The focus should be on becoming a better person through practice and reflection. By striving to embody virtuous traits, I not only improve myself but also positively influence those around me. As Proverbs 21:21 states, "Whoever pursues righteousness and kindness will find life, righteousness, and honor," emphasizing the importance of virtuous living. This assignment illustrates how different ethical frameworks can guide moral reasoning in various scenarios while also integrating biblical references that align with these principles. Each response highlights a unique aspect of morality relevant to contemporary situations we may face in daily life.    

Sample Answer