discuss the selection of instruments or tools to measure the clinical question variables. The validity and reliability of the instruments or tools will be addressed. Discuss the methods for:
• The distribution and collection of the tools,
• Addressing potential concerns for confidentiality,
• Protection of participants and,
• Application of analog or technology.
Sample Answer
Selecting Measurement Instruments
The selection of instruments or tools to measure variables in a clinical question is a critical step in research, directly impacting the quality and credibility of the findings. The choice depends on the specific variables (e.g., patient satisfaction, pain levels, quality of life) and the research design. A sound instrument must demonstrate both validity and reliability.
Validity refers to the accuracy of the instrument—does it measure what it is intended to measure? For example, a depression scale is valid if it accurately reflects a person's level of depression, not just their general mood. Types of validity include:
Content validity: Does the instrument cover all relevant aspects of the variable?
Criterion validity: Do the results correlate with another established measure (the "gold standard")?
Construct validity: Does the instrument measure the underlying theoretical concept?
Reliability refers to the consistency of the instrument—will it produce the same results under the same conditions? For example, a blood pressure cuff is reliable if it gives consistent readings when used repeatedly on the same person. Types of reliability include:
Test-retest reliability: Do results remain stable over time?
Inter-rater reliability: Do different researchers get the same results when using the same instrument?
Internal consistency: Do all the items on a scale measure the same concept?
Methods for Distribution and Collection
The method for distributing and collecting measurement tools must be efficient and secure.
Physical Distribution: For studies involving paper-based surveys or assessments, tools can be distributed in person, mailed to participants, or left in designated areas at a clinic. Collection can involve sealed drop-boxes or return envelopes.
Digital Distribution: Using technology is often more efficient. Tools can be distributed via email, secure web portals, or integrated into a mobile app. This method allows for real-time data collection and minimizes transcription errors.
Confidentiality and Participant Protection
Addressing potential concerns for confidentiality and protecting participants is a non-negotiable ethical requirement.