Critical Essay on Chronicles of the Crusades
Critical Essay on Chronicles of the Crusades
Content: introduce the work and explain the thesis and argument of your paper
You will be reading Joinville and Villehardouin’s Chronicles of the Crusades. Penguin Classics. Trans. Caroline Smith. (2009). You must use this edition of the text. You do not have to read Joinville’s “The Life of Saint Louis.”
Answer the following question:
One of the criticisms modern scholars direct toward Geoffrey of Villehardouin’s “The Conquest of Constantinople” is that it is too impersonal and does not provide a satisfactory depiction of life in the western medieval world. Do you think this is a fair criticism? Why or why not? Use specifics to support your argument. Consider social, cultural, economic, religious, political, judicial, and military factors in your decision making process. You must take a clear stance, this criticism is fair or is unfair, and express this in your thesis. In order to support your position, you must decide and explain how many factors constitute a successful depiction of life in the western medieval world.
Your answer must be supported by quotations and citations from the text (not only from the introduction), referenced accordingly. Consultation of outside sources not distributed by the instructor, especially the internet, is strictly forbidden and will result in a failing grade on the assignment. You may consult text book for background information, but quotations from this book should not be the majority of your citations.