Case study on a company
The Scenario
We will pretend that you and your partner(s) are co- CEO’s of a company called “Scorpio-No-More” (SnM). SnM is a publicly-traded, multi-national pest extermination supply company that last year
netted over 100 million dollars in sales of products killing everything from ticks to sewer rats. SnM’s sales rank it as the second-most profitable pest extermination supply company in the world
(behind Vermin-Away Enterprises), and your organization enjoys a reputation as an ethical business and employer.
Over the past six months, SnM has had a run of bad luck. Your most popular product, “Beetle Rum,” has been linked to the development of severe rashes and skin irritation by its users—to the point
that you are now facing several expensive lawsuits as well as a variety of adjustment claims from your customers. You are surprised, as “The Rum” has previously been a certified problem free
product. As you consider the issue, however, you strike on a likely cause. Last March, SnM made the decision to alter the chemical components of Beetle Rum so that the new formula, while still
deadly, was less expensive to manufacture. You conclude that your cost-cutting new formula might be the cause of your customers’ difficulties, forcing you to confront a series of exciting legal and
rhetorical challenges:
1-Despite your best efforts to recall the new Beetle Rum, several customers have served SnM with lawsuits related to complications caused by use of your product. Compose a response to Lucius
Leadpusher, attorney for one of your afflicted customers, who wants to know the exact chemical composition of Beetle Rum. You will, of course, reply courteously, but negatively.
2-Meanwhile, customers have also been contacting you directly. One of these, Charlie Chafing, has written to you requesting a refund in the amount of $389.78 (the cost of the two cases of Beetle
Rum)-- an adjustment that he feels is due because he has experienced severe symptoms since using the newer version of your product. As for as you can tell, he has used Beetle Rum properly and
according to your instructions, and after March 2016. Compose a message to him in which you agree to grant his claim.
3-Another customer, Amy Pinchpenny, has also written to you seeking a refund adjustment. Amy seeks only $15.00, the cost of a single bottle of Beetle Rum, but it is clear from reading her letter
that she is attempting to capitalize on your present difficulties. She claims that she used Beetle Rum purchased prior to March 2016-- before the chemical composition of the product changed.
Compose a message to her, denying her claim.
4- Unfortunately, Pinchpenny is not the only one that takes advantage of the situation. When you review the bill from Morgan Cashman, your recently-hired specialist attorney, you notice that she
has over-billed SnM by 22 hours. Compose a message requesting a refund adjustment for the amount that she over-billed your company.
Rules:
In addition to the completed project, you will need to document your pre-writing process. Each piece of correspondence will be submitted individually. At the foot of each message, answer the
following:
Justify your choice of message type. Why did you select the format that you did for the message? Remember—you will have your choice of blog posts, instant messages, web site announcements, emails,
memos, and formal business letters as modes of communication. Why did you feel that the format that you chose was appropriate for the particular situation? Be very specific.
Your audience analysis. Explain who they are, what their relationship is to you, what they know, how they will use the information. You will also explain how you have adapted the message for this
audience. Again… be specific!
You will provide all of the “extra” details—addresses, etc. You will have full license to supply any missing details that you deem necessary to complete your messages.
Each group will submit one copy of the completed project. Attached to this submission will be a transmission memo, which will include each group member’s name.
Everyone receives the same grade. We will not have a peer review for this assignment. Make absolutely sure that you review your partners’ work before final submission. If there is any concern about
a particular partner’s participation please let me know as soon as possible. I cannot address a problem after the documents have been submitted.