An example where data were presented on an issue
Have you seen or read about an example where data were presented on an issue, but the sample was not representative of the population from which it was drawn? If you can’t recall a specific example, locate one using an Internet search.
For this discussion, summarize the issue and respond to the following questions.
Why do you believe the sample was not representative of the population?
What are the undesirable consequences of using a poor sampling technique?
How could the inaccurate reporting of the data been prevented?
Sample Answer
A Case Study: The Literary Digest Poll of 1936
The Issue: In 1936, the Literary Digest, a popular magazine at the time, conducted a massive poll to predict the outcome of the U.S. presidential election between incumbent Franklin D. Roosevelt and Republican challenger Alf Landon. The poll famously predicted a landslide victory for Landon, but Roosevelt won by a significant margin.
Why the Sample Was Not Representative: The primary issue with the Literary Digest poll was its sampling methodology. The magazine sent out millions of ballots to individuals whose names were drawn from telephone directories and automobile registration lists. This method inherently biased the sample towards wealthier individuals who were more likely to own cars and telephones. As a result, the poll overrepresented Republicans, who tended to be wealthier at the time, and underestimated the support for Roosevelt, who was popular among lower-income voters.