An “evolutionary” approach to force design emphasizes incremental improvements and modifications to existing platforms. A “revolutionary” approach believes in bold investments toward research and development to achieve an exceptional advantage in future scenarios. Considering current and emerging threats, should your naval service pursue an evolutionary or revolutionary approach? In answering, be sure to take a clear position in favor of either the evolutionary or revolutionary approach. In addition, provide an example from naval history to support your answer.
Full Answer Section
-
Need for Disruptive Technologies: An evolutionary approach, focused on incremental improvements to existing platforms, may not be sufficient to counter these emerging threats. A revolutionary approach is necessary to:
- Develop advanced sensors and sensor fusion capabilities to detect and track threats in complex environments.
- Invest in artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning for autonomous systems, decision-making, and threat assessment.
- Develop directed energy weapons (lasers, railguns) for long-range precision strikes and defense against missiles.
- Explore advanced propulsion technologies, such as hypersonic weapons and electromagnetic railguns, to increase speed and maneuverability.
Historical Example:
The development of aircraft carriers in the early 20th century exemplifies the power of a revolutionary approach. While battleships were the dominant naval force at the time, the introduction of aircraft carriers fundamentally changed the nature of naval warfare. This revolutionary innovation provided a platform for long-range air power, enabling navies to project power over vast distances and dominate the skies above the battlefield.
Conclusion:
In the face of evolving threats, a revolutionary approach to force design is crucial for the future of naval power. By embracing cutting-edge technologies, investing in research and development, and fostering a culture of innovation, navies can maintain their operational effectiveness and ensure their ability to project power and protect national interests in the 21st century.