Title: The Ambivalent Nature of the Community’s Perception of Sula

In Toni Morrison’s novel “Sula,” the character of Sula is depicted as a rebellious and unconventional woman who defies societal norms. The assertion that the community both ostracizes Sula and is subconsciously grateful for her presence is a complex and nuanced one. This essay argues that while the community does indeed ostracize Sula, there is little evidence to suggest that they are grateful for her presence.

One of the key scenes that exemplifies the community’s ostracization of Sula is when she returns to The Bottom after being away for a long time. The narrator describes the reaction of the townspeople, stating, “They watched her come and go, but they did not come closer” (Morrison, 45). This quote illustrates how the community keeps their distance from Sula, viewing her with suspicion and disdain.

Furthermore, when Sula befriends Nel and they form a close bond, the community’s disapproval is palpable. For example, when Sula and Nel are caught laughing at a funeral, the townspeople are quick to judge and condemn them. This is evident in the following quote: “The people whispered that it was a judgment on Sula’s and Nel’s disrespect for the dead” (Morrison, 72). This demonstrates how the community uses any opportunity to criticize and isolate Sula.

Moreover, the community’s perception of Sula as a threat to their traditional values is reinforced throughout the novel. When Sula has an affair with Nel’s husband, Jude, the town’s opinion of her reaches a new low. The narrator describes the reaction of the townspeople, stating, “Sula was not evil, just different. Jude loved her and who was to say that what he felt was not love?” (Morrison, 105). This quote highlights the community’s inability to comprehend or accept Sula’s unconventional behavior, leading them to further ostracize her.

In conclusion, while it is true that the community ostracizes Sula in the novel “Sula,” there is little evidence to suggest that they are subconsciously grateful for her presence. On the contrary, the community’s disapproval and condemnation of Sula’s actions throughout the novel demonstrate their deep-seated animosity towards her. The complex relationship between Sula and the community serves as a poignant commentary on societal norms and the fear of those who dare to challenge them.